Photo by fizkes from Getty Images via Canva.com
In this article:
In competitive housing markets, renters hoping to become homeowners may pursue less traditional paths. The question, How can I buy a house?, can be a difficult one to answer, but renting-to-own is one unconventional way to achieve homeownership. Because it sounds like a simple hybrid of renting and buying, it's easy to oversimplify the transaction. While the idea is straightforward, certain variables complicate the topic. It all boils down to the type of housing market that a potential buyer or renter seeks to buy a home.
Defining a Rent-to-Own
What exactly is a rent-to-own (also called lease-to-own)?
Rent-to-own is a housing or purchasing agreement in which a person rents a property for a set period, and then has the option or requirement to buy it later. Part of the rent may go toward the eventual purchase price. This setup allows the renter to build equity or credit toward home ownership while still leasing.
Terms to Know
- Contract for Deed: A contract for deed is a sale agreement between the buyer and seller without the involvement of a third party, like a bank. Instead, the buyer makes payments directly to the seller, and the seller keeps legal ownership of the home until it’s fully paid off. The buyer typically has the right to occupy the property during this time.
- Lease Option Agreement: A lease option agreement allows the renter to either walk away or buy the home at the end of the lease. It prevents the owner from selling to anyone else before the tenant decides to buy.
- Lease Purchase Agreement: A lease purchase agreement sets a time frame for the renter to buy the property. Typically, the price is negotiated and determined in advance, but in some cases, both parties agree to set the price later when a third party is appointed to appraise the home.
Why Choose a Rent-to-Own?
For some buyers, a rent-to-own can be appealing because it offers financial flexibility. A traditional home purchase typically involves getting a mortgage, making an offer, coordinating home inspections, and closing. However, not everyone is prepared to buy a home this way.
For those with less-than-perfect credit, new jobs without an established income history, or a self-employed status, this arrangement allows them to secure a home now and buy time to qualify for a mortgage later. The setup is even more flexible if the seller is open to a contract for deed. It bypasses formalities and allows the buyer to make payments directly to the seller.
The seller's motivation for is easy to understand:
- Attract a higher-caliber tenant.
- Receive a larger amount of money up front.
- See larger profit margins should the renter choose not to buy.
The Process of Renting to Home Ownership
Non-Refundable Option Payment
In a non-refundable option payment, the renter provides the seller with a sum of money to reserve the right, or option, to buy the property during or at the end of the lease. The amount can vary, but typically falls between 1% and 5% of the purchase price. That said, in competitive markets or higher-value properties, some sellers may request closer to 5%-7%. This payment also ensures the homeowner doesn’t list the property for sale to other buyers during the option period.
The Rent-to-Own Lease
As with any lease, the details will vary. The key details to focus on are duration, which dictates how much time the seller has to save for a down payment and improve their credit score to qualify for a mortgage, and whether the agreement is a lease option or lease purchase.
A lease option allows the renter to walk away at the end of the lease. If the buyer decides the property isn’t the right fit, they can cut their losses and move on. However, if the lease is a lease purchase, there is no option. At the end of the lease term, the buyer/renter is legally obligated to buy the property.
Photo by Susannah Townsend from The Susannah Townsend Collection via Canva.com
Purchase Price
Most of the time, the purchase price is determined when the contract is signed; however, it may be set at the end of the lease.
There are pros and cons to both approaches when determining a purchase price:
- The purchase price is determined at the beginning of the lease. This can help the buyer lock in a great rate if the market continues to rise. However, there’s always the chance the property’s value could drop, and they'll end up overpaying.
- The purchase price is determined at the end of the lease. This lets the buyer settle on the most accurate, fair market value. The downside to this option is that if the home’s value increases while the buyer is leasing, they could end up paying more than if they'd locked in the price at the start.
Applying Rent to the Principal
Another factor to consider is how much of the rent is going toward the purchase price each month.
Take a look at this example:
The buyer/renter pays $1,200 in rent each month for three years, and 25% of that is credited toward the purchase. The buyer earns a $10,800 rent credit ($1,200 × 0.25 = $300; $300 × 36 months = $10,800).
Not all agreements include rent credits, so confirming this detail upfront is crucial. If it’s included, the credited portion is usually outlined in the contract and may vary from one agreement to another.
Home Maintenance
It all depends on the contract the renter signs. Unlike a traditional rental, the renter/buyer will usually be responsible for the maintenance and repairs of the property.
Because the term “home maintenance” refers to a range of responsibilities, it’s best to dig into the details. The lease should clearly outline who’s responsible for mowing the lawn, maintaining HOA standards (exterior paint, gutters, landscaping), and handling appliance repairs. It’s important to clarify who handles larger issues, such as roof damage, plumbing problems, water leaks, and other big-ticket repairs.
The End of the Lease
When the renter reaches the end of the lease, the type of contract they signed becomes critical. If the buyer signed a lease-purchase, they're legally obligated to buy the home, whether or not they're financially ready.
However, if the buyer/renter signed a lease-option, then they have a decision to make. There are two options in this situation:
- Follow through with the intent to buy the house. If so, apply any rent credits earned toward the purchase price, apply for a mortgage, and complete the sale.
- Walk away. With this option, the renter often leaves behind the non-refundable option fee and any rent credits.
Learn about home financing options: Home Financing Overview for Military Home Buyers.
The Benefits of Renting or Leasing to Own
The following options can work well for those who choose to rent-to-own.
More Time to Build a Down Payment
Sometimes, the only thing standing between a renter and homeownership is the lump sum required for a down payment. Renting before planning to buy allows more time to save the amount lenders typically require.
Avoid Buyer Competition Later
A lease-to-own agreement cuts out all the competition. By locking in the home now, the buyer avoids bidding wars and enjoys a smoother, more peaceful path to ownership.
More Time to Increase Credit Score
One of the most common reasons buyers choose rent-to-own is having less-than-perfect credit. This alternative gives the buyer time to work on their credit and get more favorable mortgage rates, while still securing the home they intend to purchase.
The Pitfalls of Rent-to-Own
In some cases, rent-to-own isn’t always the best choice. While some buyers benefit from this method, there are important factors to consider.
It Can Be More Expensive
The buyer can expect to pay more upfront, and more on a monthly basis, compared to a standard rental property. Although part of the higher costs may go toward the home’s purchase price at the end of the lease, the buyer risks losing those extra payments if they decide not to buy.
Additionally, paying more each month can make it harder for renters to save for a down payment and improve their credit score.
A less expensive rental may offer more flexibility while a buyer works on paying down debt, improving their income, boosting their credit, and qualifying for a mortgage.
Photo by Nattakorn Maneerat from Getty Images Pro
The Market Could Change
Most of the time, the purchase price for the property is determined when the buyer/renter signs the lease. This can secure a good price, but it could backfire if the market falls. To avoid this risk, it’s wise to get an appraisal, research the city’s development plans, study neighborhood trends, and predict what the home might be worth in two, three, or four years.
Tied to the Owner’s Finances
Consider this worst-case scenario. The buyer signs a lease-to-own, lives in the property for a year, maintains it, and plans to buy it in six months. However, the owner fails to make their mortgage payments, so the lender could foreclose on the home. Now the buyer is not just a tenant without a home, they're a tenant facing a significant financial loss.
Additionally, if the seller changes their mind after signing a contract, enforcing the agreement could require expensive legal action. That’s a cost the buyer may not be able or willing to pay.
Contract for Deeds (Good for Buyers, Risky for Sellers)
While rent-to-own arrangements don’t often pose major concerns for sellers, contract-for-deed agreements come with specific risks.
Suppose the homeowner accepts a contract for deed. They keep the title, but they transfer possession of the property. Instead of receiving the full value of the home upfront, they're now tied to monthly payments.
That alone might not seem like a big problem, but it can be. The loan remains on the owner's credit report, which can make it harder to qualify for a new mortgage for their next home. More importantly, since the buyer doesn’t go through a formal mortgage application process, if they default on payments or fail to comply with city codes and ordinances, the seller bears the consequences.
Tips for Buyers
1. Treat it like a traditional home purchase.
When buying a home, buyers research the area, compare properties, and learn about upcoming developments. Even though a buyer in this agreement is entering as a renter, the process should be similar. Buyers should do everything they can to confirm this property is the right fit and determine its fair market value. It’s the same as if they were applying for a home loan and making an offer today.
2. Read the lease carefully.
The paperwork can be complex. It’s wise to consult with a realtor and a lender before signing anything to help avoid potential pitfalls later.
3. Get an appraisal.
A renter wouldn’t get an appraisal for a traditional rental agreement, but this is a lease-to-buy situation. The buyer/renter must establish the property’s value before negotiating the purchase price and monthly rent.
4. Ask the landlord about a contract for deed.
A contract for deed can offer more financial freedom. Without a lender involved, it might be possible to avoid closing fees and origination fees, and potentially negotiate a lower down payment—if the landlord is open to this arrangement.
5. Use a third party.
It’s also recommended to use a neutral third party, such as an escrow service, to handle monthly rental payments. Having a clear, documented payment history can help renters qualify for a mortgage when they decide to buy the property.
Tips for Sellers
Sellers often assume more risk than with a traditional rental. However, there are two key steps they can and should take to protect themselves:
1) Use a third party to vet the buyer's credit.
2) Verify the buyer's income.
These steps help ensure the tenant is financially stable and capable of eventually purchasing the home.
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer to whether rent-to-own is the right choice. It can be a great opportunity for aspiring homeowners if they’re confident it’s the home they want to buy in a few years. However, if there’s any uncertainty, it might be better to search for “rent specials near me” while saving for a down payment or working toward mortgage approval.
If you’re ready to take the next step of homeownership, take a look at MilitaryByOwner’s listings and start your home search today!
Are you planning to buy a home? Get MilitaryByOwner's free guide below and learn how to get your finances in order before you begin the process.
