Resources

How to Manage Your Rental Property: A Practical Guide

Woman in khaki blazer sits at desk typing on computer and calculator with stack of papers on clipboard underneath.

Photo by charliepix from charliepix via Canva.com

In this article: 

 

Finding tenants is only the beginning of managing a rental property. Once they move in, you're responsible for keeping the property in good condition and making decisions that affect both your tenants and your bottom line.

Some responsibilities will become routine, while others come up when you least expect them. Knowing how you'll handle these situations ahead of time makes managing a rental property easier, whether you're doing the work yourself or hiring a professional property manager.

Managing a Rental Property: Where to Start

Before getting into the day-to-day responsibilities of managing a rental property, make sure you've covered the basics. Understanding your legal obligations and having the right insurance coverage are important starting points.

Understand the Fair Housing Act

The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in housing transactions, including the sale and rental of residential properties. For landlords, this means treating prospective and current tenants fairly and applying rental policies consistently.

The law also requires landlords to provide reasonable accommodations for people with disabilities when applicable. State and local fair housing laws may provide additional protections.

See What Homeowners and Landlords Should Know About the Fair Housing Act for more detailed information.

Landlord Insurance vs. Homeowners Insurance

A standard homeowners insurance policy ‌isn't designed for a rental property. Landlord insurance, also known as rental property insurance, is meant to protect the owner's investment when the property is occupied by renters.

Landlord insurance ‌‌‌‌covers damage to the dwelling from covered events. Depending on the policy, it also provides liability protection and coverage for lost rental income if a covered loss makes the property uninhabitable. Contact your insurance provider to review your coverage before tenants move in.

Once you've addressed these initial considerations, the next step is deciding whether to manage the property yourself or hire a professional.

Should You Self-Manage or Hire a Property Manager?

One of the first decisions you'll face is whether to manage your rental property yourself or hire a professional property manager. Each approach has advantages, depending on your budget and how much time you have available.

Managing the property yourself gives you direct control over tenant selection, maintenance decisions, and rental finances while eliminating monthly management fees. However, you'll also be responsible for the day-to-day work, including responding to tenant concerns, coordinating repairs and maintenance, collecting rent, and handling vacancies.

A property manager handles the responsibilities outlined in your management agreement, such as marketing the property, tenant screening, rent collection, and handling maintenance and repairs. Professional management is particularly useful for owners who live far away from the property, have multiple rental properties, or lack the time to oversee daily operations. 

Before deciding, consider whether the time and effort you'll save with professional management justify the additional expense.

Hiring a Property Manager

Before hiring a property manager, compare services, fees, and experience.

Check references from other property owners and verify any licensing required by your state. Request a detailed breakdown of fees, including additional charges for leasing or coordinating repairs.

Review the management agreement carefully, paying particular attention to which decisions require your approval, how expenses are handled, and the terms for ending the contract. Establish how often you'll receive financial reports and updates about the property. 

For more detailed guidance, see What to Know About Hiring a Property Manager.

How to Find and Screen Tenants

Finding reliable renters begins with marketing your property effectively. First, create a detailed listing with clear photos and accurate descriptions of the property. Include important details such as rental terms, pet policies, utilities, yard care, and community highlights.

Market your rental property through multiple channels to reach a wider audience. Advertise your rental on MilitaryByOwner if it’s near a military installation, along with other listing websites, social media, and local advertisements. 

When the rental price or availability date changes, update every listing. Remove outdated ads once the property is leased, so you're not fielding inquiries about a home that's no longer available.

Screen Prospective Tenants Carefully

Once applications start coming in, it’s important to follow a consistent screening process. Have prospective tenants complete a rental application, verify their identity and income, and review their rental history. A tenant screening service such as RentRisk is a useful screening tool.

rentrisk easy and comprehensive tenant screening

Contact previous landlords to learn more about an applicant's payment history and how they maintained the property. If you charge an application fee, it must comply with applicable state and local laws.

Use the same lawful screening criteria for every applicant and document your decisions. Federal and state fair housing laws prohibit discriminatory rental practices. The Fair Credit Reporting Act also requires certain disclosures when landlords deny an application or take another adverse action based on information in a consumer report.

See Tenant Screening Tips for Landlords.

Professional cleaning gray carpet with yellow wet/dry vacuum.

​Photo by AndreyPopov from Getty Images via Canva.com

Prepare the Property for New Tenants 

Before new tenants move in, make sure the property is clean, safe, and ready for occupancy. Complete necessary repairs and maintenance and check appliances, major home systems, and safety equipment.

Conduct a move-in inspection and document the property's condition with dated photos and a written checklist. Provide tenants with their own move-in walkthrough checklist to complete and return within a specified timeframe, asking them to note any existing damage or concerns they have. Review the completed checklist, address any issues that need attention, and provide the tenant with a copy.

This establishes a record of the home's condition at the beginning of the lease agreement and provides documentation for resolving disagreements over damage or security deposits when the tenant moves out.

Consider putting together a rental home binder for tenants, to include appliance instructions and warranties, home warranty policy, contact information, any quirks of the house, location of the water main shut-off, and neighborhood and HOA info. 

While being careful not to overwhelm, providing information about the home can limit calls and emails regarding basic questions.

How to Prepare for New Tenants breaks down the process of preparing for tenants. 

CTA_Move-InMove-Out_Checklist house and magnifying glass in black circle with tan rectangle and black text blue button

Your Rental Property’s Finances

An occupied rental property doesn't automatically mean a profitable one. Understanding your ongoing expenses and having a reliable system for managing rental income are essential to keeping your property financially healthy.

Setting Your Rent

Setting the right rental price involves balancing your expenses with what tenants are willing to pay in the local market. Pricing your rental too high risks extended vacancies, while setting it too low reduces your potential rental income.

Start by comparing five to ten nearby rental homes with similar square footage and bedroom counts. Look at recently leased properties when possible, since active listings show asking prices rather than what tenants actually pay.

Adjust your price range based on your home's condition and amenities. For example, a home with an updated kitchen and newer appliances may command more rent than a comparable property with dated finishes. A fenced yard or garage may also justify a higher price, depending on what renters in your area are looking for.

Consider local rental demand and how long comparable properties have been on the market. If similar homes have been advertised for weeks without finding tenants, that's a reason to reconsider pricing yours at the top of the range. If you're working with a property management company, ask for their recommended rate and the comparable properties supporting it.

Finally, compare your expected rental income with your ownership expenses, allowing for periods when the property sits vacant. But remember that a higher asking rent won't make up for expenses if the local market doesn't support that price.

Tip: Search MilitaryByOwner for comparable rental listings if you’re near a military base. You can also see the BAH listed by location.

Security Deposits, Collecting Rent, and Managing Late Fees 

Before collecting a security deposit, check your state and local laws. Some jurisdictions limit how much landlords charge or require deposits to be held in a separate account. You'll also need to understand the rules for returning deposits and making deductions from them when tenants move out.

Keep a record of each tenant's security deposit and don't treat it as money available for routine property expenses. The deposit generally remains refundable, subject to lawful deductions at the end of the tenancy.

Choose a consistent method for collecting rent, whether through an online payment service or direct bank transfers. Make sure tenants understand the payment deadline and how payments are recorded. Online payments simplify collection, but check when payments are considered received, particularly if transfers take several business days to process.

Late payments require a consistent approach. Your lease should specify when rent is due and any applicable grace period. State and local laws determine whether late fees are permitted and may limit the amount landlords charge. When a payment is overdue, contact the tenant promptly and keep a record of any outstanding balance or agreed-upon payment arrangements.

Budget for Maintenance and Other Expenses

The mortgage payment doesn't stop being due when your rental is vacant, and appliances rarely break down at convenient times. Set aside money for ongoing maintenance, unexpected repairs, and periods without rental income so that you're not depending on the next rent payment to cover an emergency expense.

Your budget should also account for predictable expenses, such as property taxes and insurance premiums. Keep track of the age and condition of major appliances and systems, so you can anticipate replacements and build those costs into your budget rather than relying on emergency funds.

Review your expenses periodically to determine whether rental income is covering the property's operating costs. Remember to account for vacancy periods rather than assuming you'll collect twelve months of rent every year.

Track Rental Income and Expenses

Keep rental income and expenses separate from your personal finances, and record transactions throughout the year. Save invoices and receipts for work performed on the property. These records make it easier to evaluate your actual earnings and prepare your tax return.

Rental income usually must be reported for tax purposes. Keep track of potentially deductible expenses, including eligible repairs, insurance, mortgage interest, and property taxes. 

Because the IRS treats certain improvements differently from ordinary repairs, retain documentation showing the nature of the work performed. The IRS offers guidance on rental property income, deductions, and recordkeeping.

Get more detailed information: Tips for Managing Your Rental Property’s Finances.

Man in blue button down holds hand to mouth as he concentrates on papers in other hand.

Photo by Blvckshot via Canva.com

Use a Clear Lease Agreement

A clear lease agreement establishes expectations and helps prevent misunderstandings. You’ll need to determine details such as the lease length, rent due date, late fees, security deposit requirements, and renewal terms. Also address utilities, maintenance responsibilities, smoking restrictions, and your rental’s pet policy.

Use a state-specific lease agreement, such as those provided by US Legal Forms. Have a qualified real estate attorney review the agreement if you're unfamiliar with the legal requirements in your area.

The lease should explain how tenants should report maintenance issues, expectations for upkeep, procedures for property inspections, and the circumstances under which the landlord or property manager has access to the property. Check state and local landlord-tenant laws for specific notice requirements.

Consider requiring renters insurance where permitted by law and add that to the lease agreement. Renters insurance generally protects tenants' personal property and provides certain liability coverage, while landlord insurance protects the owner's interests. Clearly stating the insurance requirements in the lease helps establish expectations about coverage and responsibilities.

The Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA)

If you're renting to military tenants, understand your responsibilities under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act (SCRA). This federal law allows qualifying service members to terminate residential leases early without penalty when they receive certain military orders, including PCS orders or deployment orders for at least 90 days. The latest guidance also covers qualifying retirement and separation orders. 

Tenants must provide proper notice and documentation, and landlords must honor these protections regardless of whether the lease includes a “military clause,” a customized agreement inserted into the lease. Neither the presence nor absence of a military clause in a lease negates the SCRA, which is federal law. 

Learn more about the SCRA and military clause.

Stay updated on landlord and renting issues and much more with our free newsletter: 

blue rectangle with envelope and militarybyowner logo for newsletter subscription

Establish Clear Communication with Tenants

Tenants shouldn't have to guess who to contact when something goes wrong or wonder whether their maintenance request has been received. Let tenants know how to contact you or the property manager, where to submit maintenance requests, and what to do in an emergency.

Establish a preferred method of communication, whether that's email, phone, text, or a property management online platform. Keep written records of important conversations, particularly those involving repairs, lease terms, and tenant concerns.

Respond to requests promptly, even when an issue can't be resolved immediately. Providing updates about scheduled repairs or maintenance delays keeps tenants informed about what to expect. Respect tenant privacy and follow applicable notice requirements before entering the property.

Stay on Top of Maintenance and Repairs

Keeping up with routine maintenance and prompt repairs is an important aspect of effective rental property management. A slow leak under the sink is a relatively small repair until it damages the cabinetry or flooring. Addressing problems when they're first reported helps avoid more expensive repairs and keeps your rental in good condition.

Create a maintenance schedule that includes regular HVAC servicing, plumbing checks, landscaping, and seasonal upkeep. Respond promptly to tenant repair requests and understand your legal obligations for keeping the property safe and habitable.

Maintain relationships with reliable contractors who handle plumbing, electrical, HVAC, and other repairs. Establish a process for responding to emergencies, including who tenants should contact after hours and how urgent repairs will be authorized.

Periodic property inspections help identify issues that tenants haven't noticed or reported. Schedule inspections according to the lease and applicable laws, provide the required notice, and document maintenance concerns that need attention.

Manage Lease Renewals and Tenant Turnover

Don't wait until the lease is about to expire to find out whether your tenants plan to stay. Check the notice requirements in your area, review the current rental rate, and begin the renewal conversation early enough to prepare for a vacancy if necessary.

When tenants move out, conduct a move-out inspection and compare the property's condition with the original inspection records, accounting for ordinary wear and tear. Follow state laws for returning security deposits and provide an itemization of what you’ve withheld for damages. Schedule cleaning and necessary repairs promptly to minimize the time your property sits vacant.

Managing a Rental Property From a Distance

Managing a rental property from another state or even country comes with additional challenges. If your tenant reports a plumbing problem while you're several states away, you need someone local who can address the situation. For military homeowners who receive PCS orders and decide to keep their homes as rental properties, managing from afar becomes part of the transition to a new duty station.

Establish relationships with reliable local contractors and identify someone nearby to assist when you're unavailable. Use online rent collection, digital lease agreements, and property management software to handle administrative tasks remotely.

You'll also need a plan for coordinating maintenance, arranging property inspections, and preparing the home between tenants. If you're stationed overseas, frequently relocating, or unable to oversee these responsibilities, the cost of hiring a local property manager may be well worth it. 

For military homeowners navigating this situation for the first time, our Guide for the Unexpected Military Landlord covers additional considerations when renting out a home after receiving PCS orders.

Person thumbing through blue accordion file folder.

Photo by Anete Lusina from Pexels via Canva.com

Keep Good Rental Property Records

If a tenant disputes a security deposit deduction, dated inspection photos and repair invoices are far more useful than trying to remember what the property looked like a year earlier. Create a system for organizing your rental property documents, whether you use digital files, property management software, or paper records.

Keep copies of the following documents, while taking steps to protect private information:

  • Signed leases
  • Rental applications
  • Screening documentation
  • Inspection reports
  • Maintenance requests and action taken
  • Invoices from contractors
  • Rent payments
  • Tenant correspondence

Organized records simplify tax preparation and provide a clear picture of your rental property's financial performance. Review and update your records regularly rather than trying to reconstruct information at the end of the year.

Handling Legal Issues and Evictions

Even with careful tenant screening and a clear lease agreement, landlords can face disputes over unpaid rent or lease violations. It’s important to address problems promptly, document any communications with tenants, and follow the procedures required by law.

If you’re facing a potential eviction of a tenant, know that eviction procedures are primarily governed by state and local laws, which vary by state and sometimes by locality. Landlords ‌must provide the required notice before filing an eviction case in court. 

Never attempt to bypass the legal process by forcing tenants out yourself. If you're considering eviction or dealing with a serious lease dispute, consult a qualified landlord-tenant attorney familiar with the laws where your property is located.

FAQs About Managing a Rental Property

Should I manage my rental property myself or hire a property manager?

Self-managing your rental eliminates management fees and gives you direct control over decisions, but it also requires time and attention. A property manager handles the services outlined in your agreement, including responsibilities such as tenant communication, maintenance, rent collection, and leasing. Consider your availability, experience, location, and budget when deciding.

How do landlords find and screen reliable renters?

Start with an accurate, well-marketed rental listing. Follow a consistent application and screening process that includes income verification, rental history, references, and appropriate credit and background checks. Apply the same lawful criteria to every applicant and follow fair housing requirements.

What are the most important steps for managing a rental property?

Successful property management involves maintaining a clear lease agreement, communicating with tenants, collecting rent, handling maintenance requests, managing expenses, and keeping accurate records. Establishing regular routines for these responsibilities helps prevent problems and keeps the property operating smoothly.

What are the benefits of renters insurance for landlords?

Renters insurance generally provides coverage for tenants' belongings and certain liability exposures, depending on the policy. Requiring it from your renters where permitted by law helps clarify insurance responsibilities and reduces confusion about coverage when a loss occurs. However, remember that it doesn't replace landlord insurance or eliminate the owner's legal obligations.

Keep Your Rental Property on Track

Managing a rental property isn't always predictable, even when you have reliable tenants and everything seems to be running smoothly. The goal isn't to anticipate every problem, but to have a plan for handling the responsibilities that come with owning a rental. Whether you're doing the work yourself or relying on a property manager, staying informed and involved helps protect your investment for the long term.

Be sure to utilize all the free landlord/tenant resources available on MilitaryByOwner, and don’t miss the updated information regularly featured on our blog. 

Get our free guide created especially for military landlords!

home with moving boxes, military uniforms, militarybyowner sign for rent and text The Military Landlord and how to download free guide

MilitaryByOwner has helped military families navigate housing and relocation decisions since 2000. Explore additional PCS resources, military housing guides, and relocation tools designed specifically for military life.

back to top

Close